HomeAmericasIndo AmericaCharlie Kirk Criticized Indian H1B Visas And Wanted Nothing To Do With Pak Conflict

Charlie Kirk Criticized Indian H1B Visas And Wanted Nothing To Do With Pak Conflict

Charlie Kirk Criticized Indian H1B Visas And Wanted Nothing To Do With Pak Conflict

Charlie Kirk Criticized Indian H1B Visas And Wanted Nothing To Do With Pak Conflict

India-West News Desk

WASHINGTON, DC – Conservative commentator Charlie Kirk, who was shot dead on a Utah university campus on September 10, leaves behind a polarizing legacy that reached well beyond U.S. politics — including his sharp takes on India’s role in global affairs and immigration.

Just days before his death, Kirk reignited debate with a post on X declaring that the United States should not expand visas for Indian professionals. “America does not need more visas for people from India,” he wrote on September 2. “Perhaps no form of legal immigration has so displaced American workers as those from India. Enough already. We’re full. Let’s finally put our own people first.”

The post, echoing long-standing MAGA talking points against skilled immigration, triggered a wave of criticism. Advocates for immigrants highlighted that Indian professionals in tech and STEM have powered Silicon Valley and the U.S. economy, while Kirk’s supporters argued that H-1B visa holders were displacing American jobs and suppressing wages. The backlash showcased how India is becoming a flashpoint in America’s culture wars over immigration.

Kirk had earlier drawn attention for his commentary on India’s conflict with Pakistan. Following the May terror attack in Pahalgam, which killed 22 people, India launched “Operation Sindoor” against militant groups. On his widely followed podcast, The Charlie Kirk Show, he dismissed calls for U.S. involvement, framing the escalation as a regional issue.

“Pakistan is 100% Muslim. India is mostly Hindu. They don’t care for each other much at all,” Kirk said, before adding that while the U.S. might “slightly favor India because they’re retaliating to Islamic terror,” Washington should offer nothing more than moral support. “This is not our war,” he emphasized.

Kirk’s positions on India reflected his broader worldview — skeptical of foreign entanglements, aligned with Donald Trump’s “America First” agenda, and uncompromising in his opposition to immigration. As founder of the youth activist group Turning Point USA, his campus rallies and media platforms — including 5.2 million followers on X and 4 million YouTube subscribers — amplified those positions to a wide audience.

Share With:
Comments
  • I was praying the war would not escalate. A war like that would kill millions, possible hundreds of million. Pakistan has to get control over its government and the warlords, part of this poverty, part is cultural.
    Thankfully things have quieted down. Trump helped a lot on this.
    Please pray now for peace in Ukraine.
    Such a peace is good morally. It likely would help US India relations as well.
    Countries must work together on these things and not shy away from our mutual responsibility to ensure peace.
    India should be one of those countries most acutely aware of this need, having faced numerous terror attacks, many emanating from Pakistan.
    So, I respect Charlie, he was overall a great guy.
    But, the US should be a little more than morally involved, but not always militarily. This should include Pakistani economic/government development help (to the extent that it can be tolerated the people of the region).
    The wisdom of Ghandi is to raise the child as a Muslim, is in play here. We are not here stamp out another culture, we are here to raise up our brothers and sisters (and that’s everyone here on Earth, in case you didn’t know).

    September 11, 2025
  • Hey Jake what kind of bullshit are you talking. Take it elsewhere or in porkistan.

    September 11, 2025
  • The MAGA followers have a limited understanding of complex economic and political events. Like Charlie Kirk, their formal education is sourced from social media, which depends on rumors, untested theories, and propaganda. According to the Labor Department, we simply do not have a local pool of qualified engineers and scientists to run the high-technology demands for several decades. H-1B visas will remain the major source for the U.S. recruitment and remain competitive in the business. For politicians, talk is easy, and the walk is difficult. Where would you find 60,000 white STEM-trained engineers per year? In the Appalachians?

    September 15, 2025
  • Well said Dalijit –
    It would definitely be better for India if we kept our talented, well educated engineers IN India .
    Let us hope that Mr Mody works on this basis.

    September 16, 2025
  • Please go back to India ASAP. Silicon Valley was a tech World-Beater before H1B with 99% American engineers. Please go back, I have found your people to be awful and vile. Go Back Go Back Now We Dont Want you !!!!!

    September 19, 2025

Leave A Comment